Methodology
Official edition · daily-1.0-baseline
How this chart is ranked
Each idea needs five distinct authors in 30 days and two posts in 14 days. The baseline weights are author reach (30%), weekly change (20%), reviewed payment signals (15%), engagement (10%), engagement velocity (10%), pain-tagged evidence (5%), authors first seen for the idea (5%) and cluster cohesion (5%). Scores use a 100-point scale and are smoothed across days. Cluster cohesion is unmeasured in the baseline. Every idea receives the same 2.5 points for it. The chart and idea breakdown show cohesion only when measured.
The edition date is the last Pacific day of evidence. The worker looks for a successful source snapshot taken between 11 p.m. and midnight Pacific on that date. It checks for publication every five minutes starting at 12:30 a.m. Pacific the following day. The October 21–November 17, 2026 editions use retrospectively reconstructed reviews and catalog mappings.
Reading the evidence
Search frequency affects weekly change. In the November 17 edition, the same searches ran 1,481 times in the earlier week and 1,008 times in the later one. Subscription cancellation showed a 43% decline. When we matched execution frequency, the estimated decline was 10%. The AI subscription audit fell about 63% under both calculations.
Reviewed payment signals count distinct authors who explicitly said they would pay for this task or reported paying for a substitute that did it. The dial counts authors in five bands (0, 1, 2–4, 5–9 and 10 or more). The score uses the weight of each author’s strongest reviewed payment post. Other authors’ willingness to pay is unknown.
Pain-tagged evidence uses one post per author in the last 30 days. We select the author’s strongest match to the idea, then calculate the share of the total match weight whose strongest problem tag was classified as pain. A high share means pain tags were common in those matches. The posts can describe problems of any severity.
First seen for this idea is the percentage of this week’s authors with no earlier match for the idea in the archive. The archive starts in October 2026, so early editions have less history for comparison. Both share dials use cutoffs at 10%, one third, two thirds and 90%.
Reach, engagement and engagement velocity use daily percentile bands with cutoffs at 10, 25, 75 and 90. Weekly change compares weighted author counts from searches present in both weeks, adding three to each count before taking the ratio. A fall of 50% or more is icy, a fall of 20% to under 50% is cool, and changes under 20% fall in the Mid band. Rises of 20% to under 50% are hot, and 50% or more is fire. Engagement velocity also uses searches present in both weeks. A grey dial with no needle means unmeasured. Dial bands are independent of the chart score.
Reading rank history
Green triangles mark gains since yesterday, red triangles mark losses, and filled markers show moves of three places or more. NEW marks a debut. Rank movement compares consecutive daily editions. Current run counts consecutive days in the Top 20. Total days includes earlier runs. A breakout marks a fresh chart high in the first seven days of an idea’s debut run. Its new peak must be at least five places above its best rank through three days ago (or its debut rank for a shorter history). Holding a peak or re-entering the chart earns no mark. The marker describes published ranks and adds no points to the score. Uncertainty ranges come from 200 author resamples.